Texas Supreme Court Clarifies Issues Regarding Wrongful Termination Cases in Texas

/ 04/27/2012

The Texas Supreme Court recently ruled on a case involving the wrongful termination of an employee because the employee refused to perform an illegal act. Safeshred, Inc. v. Martinez, No. 10-0426 (Tex. Apr. 20, 2012), available at


The employee refused to drive a truck because the truck did not comply with safety regulations. The employer fired him for this refusal. The employee then sued for wrongful termination and won. The jury awarded him punitive damages.


A narrow exception to the at-will employment doctrine allows an employee to sue an employer if the employee was fired for the sole reason that the employee refused to perform an illegal act. The Court first held that these wrongful termination claims are tort claims, not contract claims. As such, punitive damages would be appropriate if the plaintiff presented sufficient evidence of the employer’s malice. The Court provided several examples of what malice could be in a wrongful termination matter. It then concluded that the plaintiff did not present legally sufficient evidence for the jury to believe that the employer acted with malice in firing him, and it reversed the punitive damages award.


To speak to a Dallas, Texas employment lawyer about an employment law matter, contact the employment lawyers at Clouse Dunn LLP via email at or telephone at 214 220 3888. 

Press Release Contact Information:


Clouse Dunn LLP

214.220.3833 ( fax)

You May Also Like

Health News

The cosmetic and facial plastic surgery practice is hosting a grand opening celebration and ribbon cutting for its new Chattanooga state-of-the-art location.

Current News

“NEXT by TRT World Forum” Brought Together Globally Known Young Professionals

Current News

Merchants can now use the free get4it Competitive Analysis Tool to see the overall health of their store and inventory.


Everything You've Ever Learned About Marketing And Advertising Is Wrong. Everything You've Ever Heard, Everything You've Ever Tried, And Everything You've Ever Done Is...

Exit mobile version